Ruling: Prosecution Barred from Referring to eThekwini Officials as ‘Water Mafia’, but Permitted to Provide Criticism
Durban – The Democratic Alliance (DA) reports that the Durban High Court has granted the party permission to assert that “the leaders of eThekwini have failed to provide adequate water services.”
However, the court has mandated the removal of a billboard labeling eThekwini officials as a “water mafia.”
On Wednesday, 21 October 2026, Haniff Hoosen, the DA’s eThekwini Mayoral Candidate, stated that the mayor was unsuccessful in obtaining an order that would have compelled the party to retract its statement regarding the billboard.
He highlighted that the Durban High Court permitted the DA to declare: “The outgoing mayor of eThekwini, the outgoing municipal manager, and the outgoing head of water have not fulfilled their responsibilities, demonstrating negligence regarding water services and the acquisition of water tankers.”
Hoosen emphasized that the court’s ruling does not restrict the DA from critiquing the mayor, municipal manager, and head of water in relation to their performance, the condition of water services and infrastructure, as well as the management and procurement of water tankers, nor does it limit their campaigning efforts on these issues.
“The court’s decision does not obligate the DA to issue any formal apology concerning the billboard or any related content,” said Hoosen.
The DA welcomes the court’s decision.
“Our position is unequivocal: The outgoing Mayor Cyril Xaba, outgoing Municipal Manager Musa Mbhele, and outgoing Water and Sanitation Executive Director Ednick Msweli have not fulfilled their duties and must be held accountable for the ongoing water crisis in eThekwini,” Hoosen asserted.
The DA mayoral candidate noted that there are approximately 13,000 active water leaks in the city, resulting in an estimated loss of 21 billion litres of treated water every month.
“Years of neglected infrastructure, poor planning, and insufficient management have left communities without dependable water, forcing them to rely on expensive tankers — a situation that fosters the growth of the water tanker mafia,” Hoosen explained.
“It is also noteworthy that the court determined certain statements about eThekwini’s leadership are not to be claimed, as these allegations have never been made by the DA, meaning the court’s ruling does not hinder our campaign.”
- The Mayor, Municipal Manager, and Head of Water in eThekwini are involved with or linked to the Water Tanker Mafia,
- The Mayor, Municipal Manager, and Head of Water in eThekwini benefit from or are knowingly complicit in the Water Tanker Mafia,
- The Mayor, Municipal Manager, and Head of Water in eThekwini are part of, associated with, or complicit in a criminal syndicate or organized criminal activity related to water tankers.
“Our billboard urged the officials responsible for eThekwini’s water management to address the issues that enable the water tanker mafia to flourish while residents lack water access,” Hoosen remarked.
“It is crucial to point out that the court order does not apply to media outlets or members of the public who have commented on or shared the DA’s billboard.”
“Thus, the media and the public who have displayed images of the billboard are not bound by the court’s ruling.”
“The citizens of eThekwini deserve consistent water supply, accountable management of public resources, and leaders who are responsive to their performance.”
The mayoral candidate asserted that the DA will remain undeterred by this legal action, which appears to be an attempt to stifle legitimate criticism of leaders who have “failed in their responsibilities and have shown negligence regarding water services and the procurement of water tankers.”
